Dashboard > Archive > ... > Evangelism > DataPortability Logo Creative Brief
  Archive Log In | Sign Up   View a printable version of the current page.  
  DataPortability Logo Creative Brief
Added by Brady Brim-DeForest , last edited by Elias Bizannes on Nov 21, 2008  (view change)
Labels: 

UPDATE: The DataPortability Logo Contest public vote has begun. Cast your ballot!

Creative Brief

Toolbox:

 Instructions for Judges

The DataPortability Expert Panel membership has been determined.  The following instructions are for those members listed under 'The Panel' below:

  1. Read through the DataPortability Creative Brief
  2. Register for an OpenID (if you don't have one, you can obtain one from MyOpenID)
  3. Email your OpenID to dataportability.evangelists@gmail.com
  4. Log into the Expert Panel Shortlisting Application
  5. Select 15 candidates for the shortlist by ticking the 'Favourites' checkbox next to the individual entries.  Please make your selections by March 31
  6. You can discuss and comment on entries at the official DataPortability ConceptShare workspace.  If you need access, please email dataportability.evangelists@gmail.com

DataPortability Logo Competition

The DataPortability Project, formed in November 2007, is working to put existing data portability technologies, techniques, policies and initiatives in context -- for the purpose of coordinating the translation, education, advocacy and ultimately implementation of data portability. Portability is defined as both physically moving data or simply porting the context in which the data is used. For more background on the project, please see the section, What is DataPortability? below.

The Project's current logo is too similar to that of Red Hat's Fedora, so we have the opportunity to introduce a completely new logo. Our goal is to select a design that depicts the purpose of this effort and the community's energy while presenting a symbol that is immediately recognizable, and at once conveys the message and mission of the DataPortability Contest.

A panel of experts in graphic design and technology will review each submission and select fifteen finalists. These finalists will be vetted for trademark suitability concerns. At that point, the Project will open voting to the public.

 Desired Characteristics

  • Contemporary
  • Compatible with the idea of finding common ground amid complex needs and demands
  • Mindful of the ultimate "consumer" of data portability -- the Internet user -- while relevant to expert technologists
  • Able to deploy digitally as well as in conventional print
  • Lends itself to animation
  • Professional
  • Able to hold its own among other technology symbols
  • Unique
  • A recognizable symbol that is distinct from letterforms and can thus be easily internationalized

 Use Case Scenarios

  • As a website badge, indicating compatibility with DataPortability
  • Alongside other 'standards' icons such RSS

 The Process and Timeline

Judges will review the designs only; the Project, with the input of the winning designer, will create a brand identity and standards for using the logo.  We anticipate that each judge need spend only two to three hours both in an initial review of the submissions and in a potential "lightning round" that happens only if there is a wide disparity in the panel's selections.

  • Ending March 11:  Call for Entries
  • March 24-31:  Judges review all submissions and choose their fifteen best
  • April 1-5:  DataPortability reviews their selections and identifies common choices.  If there are few common choices, we will prepare a second round of voting in which a final group of fifteen designs is identified.
  • April 7-12:  If the panel's selections are all over the map, a lightning round begins, in which the panel votes on the narrowed choices to select the final fifteen.
  • Mid-April:  Vetting Logo Entries for Trademark Suitability. Of the fifteen finalists, a certain number may be disqualified, bringing us to a final number of between 10-15 entries.
  • April 15-18:  The public votes. (it ends at 11:59pm on April 18)
  • April 21-26:  DP Project begins preparation for announcement of the winner during Web 2.0 conference in San Francisco.  TO BE DECIDED:  Whether to secure a sponsor for creation of swag items. Web 2.0 Expo SF(Co-produced by O'Reilly Media and CMP Technology, April 22-25, 2008, San Francisco, CA)
  • April 28:  DataPortability Project announces winner.

The Public Voting System was generously donated by Webreakstuff.com and hosted by TechCrunch.

Legal/Trademark Issues

Relevant community discussions about trademark issues:

The Panel

If you would like to nominate an individual for the 6 member Expert Panel, please visit  the Google Groups thread

Current Members:

    • Malthe Sigurdsson, Brand director at Skype

    • Fred Oliveira, Webreakstuff.com

    • Tom Coats, Yahoo

    • Ashley Hall, Yahoo

    • Fiona McDougall, OneWorld Communications

    • Michael Pick, Smashcut Media

What is DataPortability?

Note: The below is a current work in progress, however it provides a snapshot of the generally agreed ideas behind DataPortability as a concept
 
data portability metaphors and similes 

Data portability is like...


contributors:

Phil Wolff, Elias Bizannes, Brady Brim-DeForest

The New Viral Marketing

What viral marketing was to the twentieth century Internet, data portability is to the twenty first.

With viral marketing, businesses built word of mouth into their products. So by using Hotmail, you told your friends about the service. 

With data portability, your identity is rich with social information. The very way people interact with strangers, friends, and companies will come with their social graphs, with their onlives.

Data portability is the new viral.

The Jericho Defrag

Imagine an enormous room, like an aircraft hanger. That's the Internet.

On the floor of the hanger small spaces divide the big room. Each of those web sites have walls that mark their boundaries. You can have a great time in each room, building up social capital. But the walls keep your social capital locked up. When you move from room to room, you leave your social network behind. If you look at the big room as a whole, you'll see your fragmented social capital spread in little bits all over the places.

Data portability knocks those walls down. It opens up the big room so you can step from site to site with your social capital intact. Borders, once defined by walls, are now markings on the floor, guides to what you can do with your social graph on that site.

Nouns and Verbs

A person's social graph is all nouns. Data describing you, the people and organizations in your onlife, and the history of your relationships with them.

Sites are verbs. They are actions that operate upon your nouns. They bring your nouns to life, applying unique world views, cultural norms, commercial services, and technical capabilities to your social graph.

Defusing the Social Graph Hostage Situation

Site operators hold your social graph data hostage. No matter what you do, they won't let your data leave.

DataPortability.org is the hostage negotiator, and data portability is the win-win negotiation strategy.

The Bank

Your data is like a currency: you exchange your data to a website, and in exchange they give you access, because they make money from the advertising. Imagine being able to store all your data, the currency of the information age, in a bank. And like we do with electronic funds, you can access your 'cash' wherever you are - knowing that your data is safe in the one place and always accessible.

The Marketplace

Imagine going shopping to a market, to buy some new cool things. You need money right? What happens if every one of those vendors, requires you to pay in a different currency. Wouldn't it be good, if everyone in the marketplace spoke the same language, so you could transact with everyone without having to think about currency exchange. And imagine, the 'change' you get from one vendor after breaking a big note, could be used on another vendor that uses the same currency. Getting everyone using the same standard form of exchange, makes it easier for everyone.

The Cure for Social Network Overload

Too much information from too many friends? Mailbox overflowing with invitations? Data portability quiets that noise.

The First Race to the Moon

Massive goal. Very clear definition. Literally impossible using current technology. Directed, multi-year effort.

Strategies: Invest in science and engineering. Multiple stages (Mercury, Gemini, Apollo), each of which teach you something.  Invent and test, iteratively.

The New Ad Click

Before, when you advertised online, someone clicked through to you and you knew nothing about them.

So you treated them generically. And your conversion rates were miniscule. 

Now, with data portability, people come to you with rich profiles and fresh social graphs. You know all about them. 

So you treat them personally, creating useful, compelling, engaging, meaningful experiences. 

And your conversion rates, and loyalty, grow wildly. 

Unable to render {include} Couldn't find a page to include called: What is DataPortability?

Has anyone noticed that comments often do not show up? Seems strange.

As in these comments?? Could it be the option to select hide/expand comments?

Here is the to do list that was added to this page last week.  I have moved it here for the sake of historical documentation:

 To Do List

I'm positioning this at the top of the page to capture attention and help (I hope). Submissions are closed/closing and we need to focus on getting this task through some hurdles in the next few weeks. Below are pointers to the tasks we need to cover I think - feel free to add anything that I have missed. If you have an issue with a task I have added, please leave a comment for review.

*21 March:* Not sure we have finished judge selection/recruitment - today we must close this and revisit tomorrow if there are non-takers. We must post a notice on the Flickr group site with tips about dealing with DNS issues (openDNS), number of images showing (need to join the group on Flickr not just Yahoo/Flickr member).

*21-23 March:* fine tuning brief for judges

*23 March:* close of business for late submissions at 6pm PST. Who will ensure the close off on submissions - can we do this on Flickr? We must post a closed notice on the Flickr group - who has admin access to do this?

*24 March:* capture all images from Flickr and create backups, shareable files (Navarr took care of this. The final product can be found at: [Expert Panel Shortlisting Application|http://www.gtaero.net/dplogo/])

*24 March:* midnight - brief and content links despatched to all judges

*25 March:* meeting with judges to discuss their brief - including thoughts on finalists' brief (the thinking behind this is to allow all finalists 2 days to prepare final submission for mechanical and technical requirements - not written yet - want judges to help us decide this maybe.

The rest for now: TBD 

Powered by Atlassian Confluence 2.7.1, the Enterprise Wiki. Bug/feature request - Atlassian news - Contact administrators